Right to repair or replacement in the Netherlands
As a consumer in the Netherlands, you have the right to choose between repair or replacement by the seller when a product is defective. You can only make this choice if the product breaks within the warranty period and the defect was not caused by your own actions. This right under Dutch law protects you against financial loss and ensures you get what you paid for.
Let MijnRecht.AI analyse your situation for free
The short answer
When your product becomes defective within the warranty period in the Netherlands, you may first choose between repair or a new item. The seller can only refuse your choice if it is unreasonably expensive compared to the alternative. In most cases, the seller must resolve the problem within a reasonable time and at no cost to you. If both repair and replacement are too expensive or impossible, you can ask for your money back or demand a price reduction.
What does Dutch law say?
The right to repair or replacement is established in the Dutch Civil Code (Burgerlijk Wetboek) and strengthened by European consumer legislation. Dutch law states that products must meet what you can reasonably expect: they must work as promised and be suitable for normal use. With defects, you first have the right to free repair or replacement. Only when this fails or takes too long can you demand other solutions such as a refund.
What should you watch out for?
Pay close attention to warranty periods and always keep your proof of purchase. The seller must prove that repair or replacement would be unreasonably expensive. When problems arise, keep all communication records and give the seller reasonable time to resolve the issue.
Practical example
Suppose you buy a laptop for €800 that becomes defective after 8 months. You report this to the shop and request a new laptop. The shop prefers to repair because this only costs €150, whilst a new laptop costs €800. In this case, under Dutch law the shop may refuse your choice for replacement because repair is much cheaper. However, if the repair takes longer than a month or is unsuccessful, you can still demand a new laptop.
What can you do?
Always start with a clear notification to the seller and indicate what you want: repair or replacement.
Conclusion
As a consumer in the Netherlands, you have strong rights to repair or replacement of defective products. The choice is in principle yours, unless the seller can demonstrate that your preference is unreasonably expensive. Don't hesitate to use your rights under Dutch law when a product doesn't do what you can reasonably expect.
Frequently Asked Questions
Have a legal question?
Let AI analyse your situation and discover your rights and options instantly.
Start free analysis